Carter Co. shooting suspect added to TBI’s Most Wanted, Sheriff weighs in on case details


Editor's Note: The Carter County Sheriff's Office originally reported that the shooting on Dave Buck Road occurred on Saturday, Nov. 27. That date has been corrected to Friday, Nov. 26 and confirmed with law enforcement.

UPDATE: Elijah Taylor was arrested Tuesday evening in North Carolina, according to the Carter County Sheriff’s Office.


CARTER COUNTY, Tenn. (WJHL) – After a Friday night shooting on Dave Buck Road sent one person to the hospital, authorities across the state are searching for Elijah Adam Taylor, 37, who is considered armed and dangerous.

According to a release from Carter County Sheriff Dexter Lunceford, Taylor is wanted on two counts of attempted murder after witnesses allege he “started a fight and shot at two people at a residence on Dave Buck Road” around 11:15 p.m. on Nov. 26.

Lunceford said one of those victims sustained multiple gunshot wounds from a pistol and was transported to a hospital.

The victim taken to the hospital was in “satisfactory condition” as of Nov. 30, and Lunceford said the uninjured victim was Taylor’s ex-wife. The injured party is her current boyfriend.

Lunceford said when investigators had arrived, Taylor had already fled the scene. Since he was last seen with a gun, law enforcement consider him armed and dangerous and advise anyone who sees him to remain at a distance.

While the incident occurred on Friday, Nov. 26 according to a press release from Carter County, the official announcement of an armed and dangerous suspect did not become public until 4 p.m. on Monday, Nov. 29.

When asked about the delay, Lunceford said, “I don’t run and report things.”

“That’s not my job; my job is to investigate crime,” Lunceford said. “We investigate crime, and when it’s the appropriate time we report, we do press releases.”

“If he’s out there listening, I would ask him to turn himself in,” Lunceford said. “There’s no need to put anybody else at risk. We’re not going to hurt him. He can call me if he wants to; I’ll come and get him.”

Lunceford confirmed that Taylor has a criminal record, though he stated that none were as serious as attempted murder.

The Carter County Sheriff’s Office lists Taylor’s description as follows:

  • Height: 5’4″
  • Race: White
  • Sex: Male
  • Hair: Dark/Gray, Balding
  • Identifying Marks: Neck and Chest Tattoos

In addition to local efforts, the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation (TBI) has added Taylor to the TBI’s Most Wanted list, and have announced a $2,500 reward for information that leads to his arrest.

According to TBI public information officer Susan Niland, Taylor’s addition to the list was requested by the Carter County Sheriff’s Office.

In order for someone to join the list, they must meet a handful of criteria:

  • 1. The crime must have been committed in Tennessee and the crime committed must be a “violent felony” and/or major drug trafficking crime (Class A felony); and
  • 2. The perpetrator must have been identified, and a warrant must be on file for the perpetrator’s arrest; or
  • 3. The perpetrator has escaped from a Tennessee jail or detention facility; or
  • 4. The perpetrator must have escaped from the Tennessee Department of Correction.
  • 5. The Director or his designee must approve the addition of the fugitive to the “Top Ten Most Wanted” list.

Copyright 2022 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Trending Stories

Don't Miss

More Don't Miss